There is an injustice built into the very fabric of this society, and it will undermine the nation Israel is working so hard, and in many ways successfully, to create. I am presently visiting Israel and the Palestinian territories, visiting churches of my Anglican communion, people and organizations working non-violently for justice and peace. Sadly, seeing the systemic injustice first hand, it is difficult to come to any other conclusion than it is the policy of the Israeli government to make life so difficult for Arab citizens and West Bank Palestinians that they emigrate.

I will be back in East Jerusalem this weekend, staying at a guest house near the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood. Being the anxious sort, I am not a fan of large demonstrations. But I will be there to observe and to lend my presence to what I hope will be a peaceful witness to the vision of an Israel that does indeed respect and care for all its citizens.

Thanks, Brant, for creating a safe context for these difficult but important conversations. Cotton

As for YBD above, of course people should be able to live wherever they would like – assuming of course, that they buy/rent a home that is VACANT. Kicking families out of their homes because your grandfather may have lived there 60 years ago is beyond outrageous. But let’s be honest about what is really going on here: certain elements of Israeli society wants to make Jerusalem – the City of Peace – a Jewish-only city. This should send a chill up the spine of any Jew – as well as any human being with a shred of decency and knowledge of history.

They can keep their Israeli citizenship, but they must still apply for all the same residency and travel permits required by any other Palestinian with East Jerusalem residency. Furthermore, they can expect all the rights granted to expatriates, but are otherwise not entitled to Israeli services except those granted to other Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem. This would likely include the settler-only roads in the West Bank, which would mean that these individuals would be separated from any family or friends if they live in another settlement, unless of course family reunifications were allowed for Palestinian families with split residencies. I could go on listing, but the most important legal caveat is that the Absentee Property Law would not apply to these Israeli-Palestinians until such time as it is expanded to include all the residents of East Jerusalem.

My point here is that this is what true equality would look like. Anything less (and what we have now is much less) is very blunt inequality, racially determined, and is a shame on any state claiming to be democratic and on any entity claiming to be Jewish. To allow Jewish settlers to reclaim property and thus further dispossess Palestinians is wrong, but to do so and to promise to extend the State of Israel to selectively include those settlers and not Palestinians sabotages the possibility of a separate Palestinian state. So I guess the settlers are either supporters of a bi-national state or an undemocratic one where Israelis of Palestinian descent do not have the same rights as Jewish Israelis.

Lets be honest, my idea would probably just scare away the settlers and they would make a huge stink in the Knesset and in the streets of Jerusalem, claiming that they were deprived of their rights. I firmly believe that both peoples’ rights can and must be realized simultaneously because they do not exclude one another. But to ignore the fact that the Palestinians do not have political and civil rights (and that we Israelis are the only ones blocking them) is the best way to ensure that neither are ever fully realized.

http://www.zionism-israel.com/log/archives/00000729.html

http://www.en.justjlm.org

Jews and Arabs live together in other places in the country, Yafo, Akko, Haifa, in the Galilee AND in Jerusalem itself. No one calls it “Hevronization”, so why should that be the case in Sheikh Jarrah? The stringent security you describe in the article is due to the inflamed situation these anarchist protestors (who already assaulted Knesset Member Michael Ben-Ari).

Even if they bring “thousands” (which I doubt) to this demonstration, the Jews aren’t going to leave. Jerusalem will not be re-divided and so the Arabs are just going to have to get used to having Jews in the area, just as the Arab states are going to have to get used to having Israel in their presence.