Report from Beit Ommar

14 year-old Mohammed Awad arrested by an Israeli soldier in Beit Ommar, 11/20/2010. Picture: Anne Paq/ActiveStills

As promised, here is a report from my good friend Father Cotton Fite, who is currently visiting Israel/Palestine. In this post, he personally testifies to the issue of child arrests/detentions in the West Bank village of Beit Ommar:

Sometime toward the end of January my friend Ahmad (not his real name) sent me a distressing message that the IDF had surrounded the homes of his parents, grandparents and in-laws at 2:00 am, seeking his two oldest boys, Ashraf, 15 and Nabil, 13 (again, not their real names).   At one of the homes, the husband/father worked at night so was not there when the IDF demanded entrance.  His wife was terrified and fled with her children to a relative living in an apartment above them.

Being denied entrance, the IDF broke the door, several windows and mirrors in the home before locating family members on the second floor. Before the night was out, they entered four homes of families related to Ahmad.  In each case the family answered the demand for the two boys with “No one with those names lives here.” Ahmad and his wife now require that the boys be home immediately after school to avoid the chance they will encounter an IDF patrol.

Ahmad and his extended family live in Beit Ommar, a Palestinian village of 15,000 (a little more than half way between Bethlehem and Hebron.  The surrounding Israeli settlements make growth in the village impossible and settlers are now encroaching on their farm land.

Ahmad is an extraordinary man.  Imprisoned three times during the First Intifada and beaten severely during the last imprisonment, Ahmad became convinced that non-violence was the only viable and moral strategy for resisting the occupation.  Believing resistance alone was not sufficient, however, he founded an organization dedicated to “crossing the borders” with dialogue between Israelis and Palestinians.  In a recent meeting convened in Beit Ommar a Palestinian who had been imprisoned in Hebron sat one seat away from an Israeli who commanded that prison.  And they listened respectfully to each other.

When I visited Ahmad in November he told me of his 15 year old nephew (whom we’ll call Sami) who had been roused from sleep by the IDF sometime after midnight in June 2010 and taken from his distressed family for questioning.

What Ahmad told me was, frankly, difficult to believe.  The military leveled charges (rock throwing) against Sami, but they were also after the names of other boys and adults who encouraged them. Sami was held for a little more than a week and, at some point in the interrogation, he was threatened with electrodes being attached to his genitals and told by the guards he would be like his sister and never marry.  Sami was understandably terrified and signed whatever he was told to sign.

Again, no matter what the circumstance, I had difficulty believing the Israeli military/police would threaten a 15 year old boy with torture which, in itself, amounts to torture.  Sami was eventually released to his family if they paid a fine of 500 shekels (approximately $140.00) and pledged to return Sami for questioning within an hour whenever required to do so.

This past weekend I returned to Jerusalem and to Beit Ommar the following Monday.  Before I did, however, I planned a meeting with the Jerusalem staff of the Israeli human rights organization B’tselem to discover what they knew about this particular incident with Sami.  B’tselem has field staff in Beit Ommar who had interviewed Sami after his release and received essentially the same report as I did from Ahmad.  Torture is of course illegal under any conditions and is a serious abuse when used with juveniles.  The staff of B’tselem told me that because of their work and that of others, torture is not regularly practiced, but they acknowledged there continue to be isolated incidents, even with young people.

I was also told it was a common practice of the IDF to arrest young Palestinians, telling them they were identified as rock-throwers (whether this is true or not) and demanding they name others as well as adults who organize and encourage violence. Strict laws govern the detention of juveniles in Israel and the occupied territories which B’tselem alleges, at least in the case of arrests in the Silwan neighborhood, the police “consistently breach.”  (An excellent discussion of these laws and a report on their observance by the authorities may be found in B’tselem’s December 2010 publication Caution: Children Ahead.)

Like parents anywhere, Palestinian parents are intensely protective of their children – and given the circumstances in which they live, probably more so.  Many adults must live with the constant fear of police banging at their door sometime after midnight, and children with the fear they will be awakened from sleep and taken away for questioning.  For many this is what it is to live under military occupation.

2 thoughts on “Report from Beit Ommar

  1. Laurena

    who is more cowardly – the Israeli soldier arresting a child or our political representatives who know of this and say nothing.

  2. Thomas Bauer

    Dear Rabbi Brant,

    i am shocked – at several levels.
    First, these reports are just outrageous. There is nothing, but really nothing in the world which justifies to treat kids and young people – or just any people ! – in this way. There is nothing – in any religion – which allows this. How can people do this ?! How can they dare to do such hideous things ??
    But then, there is this huge response to this post. Other posts in your blog draw much more attention, but this one here, as well as the previous ones on this subject, seem to go virtually unnoticed. Your visitors are not a “silent majority” – but where is their outcry? Does this mean that those who read your blog have nothing to say about this? Do they not care about what is going on? Or are they – just as i was when i read the first and second time here in your blog about this abuse of kids as hostage – are they just speechless? shocked beyond any measure? unable to say or write something reasonable?

    And then there is the most important reason why i feel shocked: What can we, what can i do about it? How can i help to stop this ?
    I start to feel guilty about this – but how can i help ? Spreading the message, showing to people what is going wrong?

    How can we act in order to help?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s