Israel Seeks Attack on Iran (aka “Politics as Usual”)

Netanyahu is seeking support in his cabinet for a military attack on Iran. Shimon Peres has just said an attack is “more and more likely.” This, despite the fact that numerous leaders in Israel’s security establishment, including former Mossad chief Meir Dagan, feel that such action would be disastrous.

Make no mistake: this has nothing to do with any imminent threat and everything to do with politics. Even Defense Minister Ehud Barak has said publicly he doesn’t believe Iran would ever drop a nuclear bomb on Israel.

So why this latest panic? Ha’aretz columnist Akiva Eldar hits it right on the head: Netanyahu knows that Obama is politically hamstrung on this issue and he smells serious blood in the water:

(Newt) Gingrich…declared at the week’s end that if the Israeli prime minister reaches the conclusion that the country is in danger, no American president could doubt it and expect Israel to sit with its arms folded and face the danger of another Holocaust. One of his rivals for the candidacy, Rick Perry, then hastened to announce that if Israel decided to attack Iran, he would demand that the United States stand behind it.

What do they have to lose? If this is a false threat designed to goad the United States into exerting more pressure on Tehran, they can wave their support. If a military assault is a new version of the last war in Iraq, they will be able to place the blame on President Barack Obama.

The problem with all this political saber-rattling, as Iran analyst Trita Parsi correctly points out, is that the more Israel presses its cynical “another Holocaust” narrative against Iran, the harder it will be “for any Israeli politician to walk back the threat depiction without losing critical political capital at home.” In other words, all this political bluster could well create a disastrous military fait accomplis.

Last word to David Remnick, who recently posted an important piece on this subject in the New Yorker blog:

A unilateral attack from Israel…would be a grave mistake for all the reasons made plain by Meir Dagan and so many others. It is terrible enough to imagine what might happen if Iran came to possess a bomb; but an attack now would almost certainly lead to a tide of blood in the region. The Middle East today is in a state of fragile possibility, full of peril, to be sure, but also pregnant with promise. A premature unilateral attack could upend everything and one result of many would be an Israel under fire, under attack, and more deeply isolated than ever before.


5 Comments on “Israel Seeks Attack on Iran (aka “Politics as Usual”)”

  1. For more information about iran you can sign up via The Fellowship of Reconciliation which has a program to prevent war with Iran. FORUSA.org

  2. […] Israel Seeks Attack on Iran Again (aka “Politics as Usual”) […]

  3. Ruth Rosen says:

    OY VEY!

  4. Laurie says:

    Why would one attack a nation that says they have nuclear capability? Netanyahu just keeps dragging the U.S. further and further into the mire of its cesspool. Who is going to have the courage to say NO to this monster!?? There are so many people who write and call and say to those in power – Please say NO to Israel – but they just keep on doing what they please!! What else can we do except throw ourselves “in front of the train”???

  5. […] Re: The Obama Presidency Originally Posted by cnmarchant "Phfft! Facts. You can use them to prove anything." Another great piece from the most excellent Rabbi Rosen, with informative links – Israel Seeks Attack on Iran (aka “Politics as Usual”) | Shalom Rav […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s